'On The Basis Of Sex' And 'Vice': 2 Biopics — 1 Bathed In Light, 1 Steeped In Shadow

作者:未知 来源:美国国家公共电台 2018-12-27


Two films opened today with titles that make them sound a lot sexier than they are. One is called "Vice" and the other "On The Basis Of Sex." What they are is biopics about a conservative vice president and a liberal Supreme Court justice. Critic Bob Mondello says the film's differences go way beyond politics.

BOB MONDELLO, BYLINE: You know exactly what you're getting with "On The Basis Of Sex" from the opening moment, when a very young Ruth Bader Ginsburg strides into Harvard Law School surrounded by a sea of gray, black and navy business suits. The year is 1956, and at first, she's the only person you see in heels - cinematic shorthand. Times were different then. And when the law dean hosts a dinner party for the nine Harvard women in a class of hundreds, you're encouraged to bristle, as Ruth does.


SAM WATERSTON: (As Erwin Griswold) Let us go around the table. And each of you ladies report who you are where, you're from and why you're occupying a place at Harvard that could have gone to a man.

MONDELLO: After she graduates, things aren't much better. New York law firms won't hire Ginsburg, so she ends up teaching law. And then her husband comes to her with a tax case he's working on that he thinks might be up her alley - and it is.


FELICITY JONES: (As Ruth Bader Ginsburg) This is sex-based discrimination against a man.

ARNIE HAMMER: (As Martin Ginsburg) Poor guy.

JONES: (As Ruth Bader Ginsburg) If a federal court ruled that this law is unconstitutional, then it could become the precedent others refer to and build on. Men and women both - it could topple the whole damn system of discrimination.

MONDELLO: Director Mimi Leder's approach to the story of a genuinely remarkable woman is genuinely remarkably conventional. There are hurdles jumped, doubts overcome, inspirational music, an earnest performance by Felicity Jones and a climactic courtroom scene that "On The Basis Of Sex" treats almost as a sporting event. Can she get her argument across the finish line? On the basis of cinematic precedents, that is never very much in question.

You'd think "Vice" about Vice President Dick Cheney would be equally unsurprising. It's not like we don't know how his story turned out. But "Vice" is by Adam McKay, the guy who made credit default swaps cool in "The Big Short" and cut his teeth on "Saturday Night Live." And he doesn't generally give audiences what they're expecting. Take the moment when a young, intensely devoted Dick Cheney - played by Christian Bale, who gained 40 pounds for the role - is interning for a youngish Congressman Donald Rumsfeld and asks his mentor a question.


CHRISTIAN BALE: (As Dick Cheney) What do we believe?

MONDELLO: Steve Carell's Rumsfeld takes in his protege.


STEVE CARELL: (As Donald Rumsfeld, laughing) What do we believe? Oh, that's very good. What do we believe? (Laughter).

MONDELLO: This is early on, and Bale's Cheney is nothing if not a quick study, Machiavellian, with a wife as hungry for power as he, at least according to the narrator, who pops in occasionally to muse about, say, the impossibility of knowing what the Cheneys were thinking when they realized George W. Bush was going to offer him the vice presidency.


UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As narrator) You can't just snap into a Shakespearean soliloquy that dramatizes every feeling and motivation. It's just not the way the world works.

MONDELLO: It is, however, how an Adam McKay movie works.


BALE: (As Dick Cheney) A mere treaty is our union.

AMY ADAMS: (As Lynne Cheney) My own blood and will are yours, to pierced be the last soldier's breastplate spilling forth its ruby jelly treasures.

MONDELLO: Growling, gruff and grumpy, Christian Bale makes the title character a lot like his Batman - basically a psychopath-turned-vigilante. Amy Adams is sharp as his Lady Macbeth.


ADAMS: (As Lynne Cheney) Half the room wants to be us. The other half hears us.

MONDELLO: And Sam Rockwell is a great foil as Dubya (ph).


SAM ROCKWELL: (As George W. Bush) I want you to be my VP. You're the solution to my problem.

BALE: (As Dick Cheney) The vice presidency is mostly a symbolic job.

ROCKWELL: (As George W. Bush) I can see how that wouldn't be enticing to you.

BALE: (As Dick Cheney) However...

MONDELLO: McCay views Cheney as responsible for most of the things that are wrong with the world today, and he pursues that notion with take-no-prisoners zeal, also with considerable cleverness from the fishing lures in the shape of Twin Towers and oil derricks that grace the final credits to the waiter who offers Cheney and other diners a menu of governmental horrors.


UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: (As character) Tonight, we're offering the enemy combatant, whereby by a person is not a prisoner of war or a criminal, which means, of course, that he has absolutely no protection under the law. We're also offering an extraordinary rendition where suspects are...

MONDELLO: "Vice" is as entertainingly negative about the vice president as "On The Basis Of Sex" is blandly positive about the future Supreme Court justice. So it's Christmas - choose your poison. I'm Bob Mondello.





    Scientific American 60s

    The Economist